Showing posts with label scripture study. Show all posts
Showing posts with label scripture study. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 27, 2015

Brothers of Jesus: a Catholic Response


Jesus did not have biological siblings. 


This is not made up by the Catholic Church. The Church has few points of doctrine or dogma when it comes to interpreting the Scripture on any matter. What does the Church teach about the siblings of Jesus:

  • Catechism of the Catholic Church with cited sources at the bottom of that page
  • 499 The deepening of faith in the virginal motherhood led the Church to confess Mary's real and perpetual virginity even in the act of giving birth to the Son of God made man.154 In fact, Christ's birth "did not diminish his mother's virginal integrity but sanctified it."155 And so the liturgy of the Church celebrates Mary as Aeiparthenos, the "Ever-virgin".156
    500 Against this doctrine the objection is sometimes raised that the Bible mentions brothers and sisters of Jesus.157 The Church has always understood these passages as not referring to other children of the Virgin Mary. In fact James and Joseph, "brothers of Jesus", are the sons of another Mary, a disciple of Christ, whom St. Matthew significantly calls "the other Mary".158 They are close relations of Jesus, according to an Old Testament expression.159
    501 Jesus is Mary's only son, but her spiritual motherhood extends to all men whom indeed he came to save: "The Son whom she brought forth is he whom God placed as the first-born among many brethren, that is, the faithful in whose generation and formation she co-operates with a mother's love."160
  • 154 Cf. DS 291; 294; 427; 442; 503; 571; 1880. (DS is actually the Enchiridion Symbolrum - abbreviated here according to its editors' names)
    155 LG 57. (Lumen Gentium)
    156 Cf. LG 52.
    157 Cf. Mk 3:31-35; 6:3; 1 Cor 9:5; Gal 1:19.
    158 Mt 13:55; 28:1; cf. Mt 27:56.
    159 Cf. Gen 13:8; 14:16; 29:15; etc.
    160 LG 63; cf. Jn 19:26-27; Rom 8:29; Rev 12:17.
On the Perpetual Virginity of the Blessed Virgin Mary by St. Jerome

What is open to interpretation - possible theories of the reference to "brothers": 
  • Joseph's children by a previous marriage - not likely since they would have been mentioned in the Infancy narratives (all that traveling). While this theory has some basis in the protoevangelium, it would be nice if Catholics let it quietly slip away, because the evidence in the inspired Gospels doesn't hold up. 
  • The original language used could have meant "other extended family" - akin to "brethren." Maybe. It holds up to scrutiny when you consider the number of times the disciples (the 12 and all the others who followed Jesus) and the apostles (specifically the 12) are referred to as brothers as opposed to the other group. (see references noted above)

Evidence that Jesus did not have brothers:

  • No siblings are mentioned during the Infancy Narratives pre-Egypt
  • No siblings are mentioned during the return from Egypt. ("Take the child and His mother")
  • No siblings are mentioned when Jesus was 12 and stayed behind in the Temple. Were they all born after Jesus was already 12? 
  • Mary was given into the care of John - what was wrong with the siblings who had allegedly been with her when He said, "Who are my mother and brothers?" and the variety of other citations used by Protestants to prove that Mary had other children of her own womb. 

Finally, no evidence here, but a thoughtful question: 
Joseph knew that Jesus was the Child of the Holy Spirit - the angel told him that - would he seriously dare to have such physical relations with the woman who carried this precious Child in her womb? Even if, especially if, he didn't fully understand, the lack of understanding alone would put the fear of God into him. 

Just because the Scriptures say, "He did not have relations with her until she gave birth to her firstborn," does not then have to lead to the conclusion that he did have relations with her afterward. 
St. Paul's quotation from Psalm 109:1, "For He must reign 'until' He has put all enemies under His feet.'" (1 Cor.15:25) ---- and then He no longer reigns? Um. Nope. He keeps reigning! 


And firstborn? My firstborn is 9 years old, sitting at the coffee table creating a "Math Wizardry" notebook. He is and always will be my firstborn. He has zero younger brothers and sisters. The lack of siblings does not remove his title as "my firstborn". Nor does a lack of Jesus' siblings strip away His title of Firstborn. 


(This post was written several months back - my son is now a bit older - still my firstborn - and only born ;) )


Thursday, September 12, 2013

What is the Bible? Study Cards - Command Cards

Several years ago, I came across some Bible study cards. I edited them and began using them at home with my son. I am not sure of my original source, but I know I did not purchase them... and I've edited a bit. So I think I am ok to share these for free :)

Then one of our local atriums had a situation that these cards seem perfect to fulfill - so I edited them a smidgeon again, re-printed and sent them over.

The oldest children in level 2 and our level 3 children heavily utilize them to get their hands back into the Bible, seeking, exploring, organizing and truly experiencing the Bible.

They are in need of another revision! Very soon, I will be updating the set to include a "Part 2" for children who have had them for a while and are looking for deeper work. I have taken some ideas from the children to implement and am currently working a couple of groups of children who are revealing to me the next steps in this work.

While these are not an official atrium material, we are using them in level 2 (for the 3rd graders) and in level 3 (for all those who have not yet done them, or it has been a while and they need a reminder).

I would love the feedback of others as well!

What is the Bible? Study Cards


Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Genesis Chapter 25


This is not specifically atrium - I am adding it here because my son has been in atrium with me for 8 years. This past year being is first in level 3 (a year early) - and he reads the Bible a bit different from your average child. I'm not bragging there ;) He reads the Bible like a child has been in level 1 atrium almost continuously for 8 years (at least once a week; sometimes 4-6 times); in level 2 almost continuously for 7 years (at least once a week; sometimes 3-5); and level 3 for a year. Not to mention all the formation courses he has attended! and even assisted!

We have started a sequence of reading through the Bible in a year. At the time of writing this, we are still in Genesis.

Chapter 25 to be specific.

How many times I've read this passage and only THIS time did I really read it. And he picked up on it too.

We all know that Abraham had two sons: as Abram, he bore a son by his wife's maid (Ishmael); then the covenant was completed, his name changed to Abraham and Sarah bore him a son in her old age: Isaac.

DID YOU KNOW?

After the death of Sarah, Isaac took solace in his wife Rebekkah (Genesis 24:67b).

After the death of Sarah, Abraham took solace in a new wife: Keturah.

This one seems accurate - 9 brothers;
but what about their ages? 

DID YOU KNOW? 

Ishmael had 12 sons to rule over 12 tribes.

Isaac grandfathered 11 boys; one boy had two sons to replace him; making what we know as the 12 tribes of Israel.
Side note: Joseph had two sons from whom 2 tribes received their names; Joseph did not have a tribe named after him. Benjamin being the younger brother, this means that only 9 brothers (at most because perhaps some were toddlers!) participated in any way in the selling of Joseph to the Egyptians.
I wish those people who write children's Bibles would at least get the stories ACCURATE.

Keturah bore 6 sons to Abraham; their ultimate descendants as listed come to 13, so it doesn't fit above; all 6 original sons were given grants and sent away from Isaac (probably because of what happened between Isaac and Ishmael).

DID YOU KNOW? 

Abraham, therefore, bore 8 sons. Not 1, not 2. EIGHT.

8. That's an interesting number. 8th day of creation (Easter); 8 people on the Ark.....

Isaac and Ishmael were together at their father's burial. Ishmael was a legitimate son, if not the "first-born" according to the birthright, because his mother was given in place of Sarah - not as a concubine, but as a replacement for Sarah's own womb. When Sarah was then able to bear a child, Ishmael maintained his legitimacy as a child of the Abraham, but lost his birthright as first-born. The other boys were considered to be conceived by "concubinage" despite Sarah being deceased at the time.

Wow.


Just one chapter. And that's not the whole thing!



That same chapter contains the birth of the twins: Esau and Jacob. Interesting that we usually consider Rebekkah to be something of a brat in her preference for the younger son. But indeed -while pregnant with the twins, she felt them wrestling and went to the Lord - the Lord told her that the older would serve the younger; indeed that he would "surpass" his older brother. Hence, she was simply favoring the one the Lord told her would rule.

Hm.


And there's still so much more said in just a few words - the age of the parents involved; how many years would that have been praying for children? the selling of the birthright....


Your turn!


;)